Replacing Window Sills

This story shows you how to replace a windowsill.


A windowsill is the part that extends outside the house; what is commonly called an interior sill is technically the stool. A wood sill is one of the few exterior surfaces that presents a horizontal face to theelements, making it vulnerable to rot.

Check the extent of rot by poking with a screwdriver; where you can easily push in, the wood is rotted. If the sill is rotted near the exterio casing, the casing may be rotted as well. If the sill is rotted all the way thorugh, the house's framing or siding may be rotted as well.

If the rot is localized, use wood hardener and two-part epoxy filler to repair it. Replacing a sill is tricky but only requires basic carpentry skills. If the old sill is so rotted that you cannot use it as a template, measuring and cutting will be more difficult.

Buy special sill stock or cut the sill our of 2x6 (1 1/2 x 5 1/2 inches). If the sill is 1 inch thick, use 5/4 decking or buy special sill stock. Use pressure-treated lumber to resist rot.

Prestart Checklist

About half a day to remove an old sill and replace it.

Hammer, tape measure, flat pry bar, circular saw or poer mitersaw, handsaw, small hacksaw, large slip-joint pliers, reciprocating saw, drill, sawhorses

Basic carpentry skills

Spread a drop cloth on the floor near the window and protect the plants outside. Set up a pair of sawhorses.

Lumber to match the sill in thickness and width (its OK if it's wider), shims, galvanized nails or decking screws, primer and paint.

Step 1

Start by removing the stool. You may need to remove the interior casing molding first. Some stools are rabbeted and overlap the sill. Others are straight and simply butt up against the sill. To remove a rabbeted stool, pry it up from the outside. Pry out a straight stool from the inside.

Step 2

If the sill is so rotted you will not be able to use it as a template (step 4), measure its thickness, width, inside length, and outside length or make a cardboard template. Use a handsaw or reciprocating saw to cut through the sill in two places (to produce three pieces).

Step 3

Use a flat pry bar to pry out the middle piece and then the side pieces. You may need to use a reciprocating saw or small hacksaw to cut through the nails that poke through the jambs on each side. Or use slip-joint pliers to pull them out.

Step 4

Place the three pieces on top of the new lumber and mark the new piece for cutting. The sill is likely beveled at the outside edge. If you buy sill stock, this bevel will already be cut. Otherwise cut it with a circular saw or tablesaw.

Step 5

Cut the sill to length and start the notches with a circular saw or power mitersaw. Finish the notch cuts with a handsaw or reciprocating saw.

Step 6

Push the new sill into the jamb grooves on each side. If you need to tap it into place, use a piece of scrap lumber to protect the sill. If needed, insert shims under the sill so it rests firmly on framing. If the stool is straight, you will need to shim it as well.

Step 7

Attach the sill by driving screws up and into the jambs. Push in shims as needed to make the sill firm at all points.

Step 8

Angle-drive nails from the top and into framing below. If possible do this only where the nails will be covered by the molding. Replace the apron and the casing.

Step 9

After all the trim is installed, apply exterior caulking to the joints. Prime and paint the sill.

Comments (4)
Add your comment

You must be logged in to leave a comment. Register | Log In
One Hour or Less

Three simple projects to cross off of your to-do list -- just print these instructions and begin!